Series Sum-Up: at Philadelphia, May 25-27

Russell Martin


Game 1: Friday, May 25th
JAYS WIN!!! 6-5
Winning Pitcher: Sam Gaviglio
Save: Ryan Tepera


The Jays capitalized on some errors early in the game, before it turned into a bit of a nail-biter at the end. Josh Donaldson doubled in the 1st, and scored as Teoscar Hernandez reached on an infield single with two outs. Yangervis Solarte and Kevin Pillar then hit back-to-back doubles, giving Sam Gaviglio a 3-0 lead before he even took the mound. Gaviglio set down the first eight batters in a row, and also hit a double in the 2nd, before allowing the first hit. That was a home run by the opposing pitcher, Zach Eflin, in the 3rd.


banner ad


Gaviglio escaped a jam in the 4th with two on base (both walks). A potential double play failed when he failed to catch the ball while covering first base. But he then induced a groundout to strand runners at the corners. Toronto widened their lead with a three-run 5th inning, including a two-run homer from Justin Smoak. Solarte singled with two out, advanced on a passed ball, and Pillar reached when a throw by Maikel Franco pulled the first baseman Carlos Santana off the base. Eflin left the game after that, and Russell Martin singled to score Solarte.


That single was one of just two that would be allowed by the Philadelphia bullpen. The other (a Justin Smoak infield single in the 8th) was erased on a double play. Santana hit a two-run homer in the 6th, cutting Toronto’s lead to 6-3. Seunghwan Oh allowed a leadoff walk in the 7th, but stranded it. Tyler Clippard allowed a run on back-to-back doubles to start the 8th. Ryan Tepera was brought in to close things out. After a one-out single between infielders, a double, and a run scoring on a wild pitch, he walked a pair. That loaded the bases, but he shortly got a strikeout and a groundout to end the game.


Game 2: Saturday, May 26th
Jays lose, 1-2
Starting Pitcher: Jaime Garcia
Losing Pitcher: Joe Biagini


This game was hard-fought by both starters, but ultimately it was the bullpen which made the difference. Jaime Garcia had a strong game after returning from the disabled list, pitching seven innings of one-run ball. He got some help from defenders in unusual positions, including a backhanded catch from Curtis Granderson in center field, and a strong throw from Russell Martin playing shortstop. It was a leadoff home run from Maikel Franco in the 4th that broke the scoreless tie. Garcia’s start – with five hits, five strikeouts and no walks – might have grabbed the headlines if not for Aaron Nola taking a no-hitter into the 7th inning.


Josh Donaldson walked in the 1st, but Nola retired the next 18 batters in order, including three strikeouts in the 6th, before walking Justin Smoak in the 7th. In that time, not one batted ball from a Blue Jay had left the infield. Nola walked Yangervis Solarte with two out, and Russell Martin laced a single into left field, scoring Smoak, tying the game, and ending the no-hitter. Nola left the field to a standing ovation (including from Martin himself).



Garcia stranded two singles (one a bunt back to the mound) in the bottom of the 7th, and was lifted for a pinch-hitter in Kevin Pillar. Pillar had an infield single, but Granderson hit into a double play. Joe Biagini began the 8th, making his first relief appearance of the season, and Nick Williams homered on his second pitch. Biagini got the next two batters before Aaron Loup came in, hit a batter, and ended the inning. In the top of the 9th, Donaldson reached on a ball to the third baseman, but Smoak struck out for the third time in the game, and Teoscar Hernandez hit into a game-ending double play.


Game 3: Sunday, May 27th
JAYS WIN!! 5-3
Winning Pitcher: J.A. Happ
Save: Ryan Tepera


The Blue Jays faced Nick Pivetta for five innings and scored two runs off him. J.A. Happ allowed the same number of earned runs (plus one unearned) in 6 2/3 innings. Curtis Granderson led off the game with a single, and advanced two bases when Pivetta made an error while trying to pick him off. He was stranded at third. In the 2nd, Russell Martin and Dwight Smith Jr. took back-to-back walks, advanced on a wild pitch, and Devon Travis hit a double to bring them both in.



With Pivetta out of the game after the 5th, the Jays hung a two-run, three-hit inning on Tommy Hunter. Smith drove in both runs, hitting a shallow double down the left-field line with the bases loaded. Hunter left the game with two out, and Travis was intentionally walked to load the bases again before Happ struck out to end it.



Happ kept the Phillies off the board through five, stranding one in the 2nd, two in the 4th, and a leadoff Scott Kingery double in the 5th. After a one-out single in the 6th, Carlos Santana reached on a grounder to third that Josh Donaldson barehanded but made a wide throw. Aaron Altherr singled to center field and one run scored, but Kevin Pillar failed to pick up the ball and Santana scored on what was ruled an error. Nick Williams singled to score Altherr, then Happ got two quick outs to end the inning.


He began the 7th, and was lifted after getting the first two batters. Seung-hwan Oh got four outs with 15 pitches, including two strikeouts. Curtis Granderson gave the Jays some breathing room with a home run in the 9th. Ryan Tepera walked the leadoff man in the 9th, got a forceout, and then got a double play to pick up the save. The Blue Jays had eight hits, while the Phillies had six. Pillar had three hard-hit balls in this game, but two were right at infielders for lineouts, and one was robbed by a diving Kingery.


Overall Notes:

Dalton Pompey didn’t appear in a game before he was sent back down to Buffalo on Saturday, to coincide with Jaime Garcia’s return from the disabled list.


My favourite player(s) this series: Gaviglio/Garcia/Oh/Happ

Sam Gaviglio’s start was, relatively speaking, one of his worst performances so far with the team – and he still lasted six innings! He only gave up three hits, but two were home runs, and they drove in all three of his runs allowed. He walked a pair and struck out six, but also picked up a double of his own.


Jaime Garcia had just returned from the disabled list with a sore shoulder, but you wouldn’t know it by his performance on Saturday. He allowed one run in a seven-inning start, and with his pitch count at only 73 pitches, I’m inclined to think he would have begun the 8th if they were in an American League park. Instead, he was removed for a pinch-hitter with the game tied. The Phillies had five hits off the lefty, but only one (Franco’s home run) was for extra bases, and he didn’t walk anybody.


Seunghwan Oh was the most dominant Blue Jays reliever in this series, in 2 1/3 innings of work. In two appearances, he had only one runner allowed – a walk on Friday – and struck out four. He helped maintain a narrow one-run lead by getting four outs on Sunday. His ERA is now at 2.08 for May, and 2.22 for the year, which the best among relievers who’ve been with the team since Opening Day.


Stop me if you’ve heard this one before, but J.A. Happ was great. He pitched into the 7th inning with eight strikeouts, six hits, and two walks. Things got a bit messy in the 6th due to a couple of errors, but he got out of it to maintain the lead. Even with that, he only had two earned runs allowed.


Where we are now:
25-28, .472
4th place in the AL East, 11 games back of Boston


Hey look, a series win! It’s been a while since we’ve seen one of those.

On Monday, the Blue Jays will kick off a series in Boston against the first-place Red Sox. Monday will be a day game because of the Memorial Day holiday in the United States, and Wednesday will be too. The Jays will avoid Chris Sale this series. Aaron Sanchez will take the mound on Monday, going up against David Price. Sanchez has already faced the Red Sox twice this season, taking a no-decision while allowing two earned runs both times.


Follow me on Twitter: @JaysGirlEmily 

If you like us here, like us on Facebook

The 2018 Toronto Blue Jays Minor League Handbook is now available! Visit the Handbook page for more information!

Now is a great time to subscribe to the Blue Jays from Away Premium Content Section!

All photos are copyright Blue Jays from Away (2013-2017) and may not be used without permission.