Series Sum-Up: May 17-20 vs Oakland


A few years ago, when I started writing these sum-ups, I used to include a cute animal video to cheer people up if a series went particularly badly. I’ve decided to do that again now, because this series was pretty painful. So here’s a puppy!



Game 1: Thursday, May 17th
Jays lose, 5-10
Losing Pitcher: Aaron Sanchez


Aaron Sanchez left the game after throwing 100 pitches. However, that only took him into the 5th inning. He threw 29 in the 1st inning alone, when two walks and a single loaded the bases for the Athletics. Sanchez got a strikeout to end the inning, and the Jays took a 1-0 lead in the 2nd when Kevin Pillar hit a leadoff double, advanced on a fly out, and scored on a fielder’s choice. Sanchez needed a further 27 pitches to get through the 3rd, when Matt Joyce singled, Jedd Lowrie doubled to score him, and Khris Davis hit a two-run homer.


banner ad


Andrew Triggs, the Athletics’ starter, left the game in the 3rd inning due to some numbness in his fingers. He had just walked Josh Donaldson on four pitches with one out. In the 4th, Pillar singled and Russell Martin walked with nobody out, but Kendrys Morales hit into a double play. Sanchez walked the first better of the 5th and then was pulled. Seunghwan Oh faced seven batters, and the first three reached: a single by Davis, a three-run homer from Matt Olson, and a Matt Chapman double. Chapman then scored on a Dustin Fowler single to put Oakland ahead 7-1. After a two-out walk, Aaron Loup ended the inning.


In the bottom of that inning, the Jays rallied for three runs thanks to three hits, a walk, a wild pitch and a sacrifice fly. But the hope was short-lived, as Oakland widened the lead with a two-run Chapman homer off Axford in the next inning. In the 8th, Toronto loaded the bases with two outs and Curtis Granderson walked to force in a run. Josh Donaldson ended that rally by grounding out. The A’s got that run back too, as Marcus Semien singled in the 9th, advanced on a passed ball, and scored on a single from Joyce. The Jays had half as many hits (seven) as their opponents, and left nine men on base.


Game 2: Friday, May 18th
Jays lose, 1-3
Losing Pitcher: Marco Estrada


Marco Estrada was outstanding through the first 6 innings of his start, with the lone blemish being a home run to Dustin Fowler in the 3rd. Estrada also stranded doubles in the 2nd, 4th, and 6th innings – those were his only other baserunners allowed up to that point. Oakland’s starter, Brett Anderson, had to leave the game after just one inning with a sore shoulder. The Blue Jays couldn’t take advantage of the bullpen, and after three innings from Josh Lucas they’d struck out six times and gotten one baserunner (Josh Donaldson walked to lead off the 4th).


Lucas began the 5th, gave up a Luke Maile double and a Gio Urshela RBI single to tie the game at 1 run apiece, and was then removed. Donaldson walked again in the 6th, again leading off, and again on four pitches, but nothing came of it, even after he stole second. They got two men on in the 8th, but Kevin Pillar struck out, ending that rally. Blue Jays batters racked up fifteen strikeouts, and had just six hits.



Two outs into the 7th, everything melted down for Estrada. Three consecutive batters (Chad Pinder, Fowler, and Josh Phegley) doubled, and two runs scored. He’d allowed seven hits (all for extra bases) no walks, and six strikeouts. All three runs were driven in by the 8- and 9-hitters in the Athletics’ lineup. Danny Barnes got out of that inning, then got two outs and allowed a single in the 8th before being replaced with Aaron Loup. Ryan Tepera took over for the 9th, gave up a double to Matt Chapman, but picked him off second base.



Game 3: Saturday, May 19th
Jays lose, 4-5
Starting Pitcher: Sam Gaviglio
Losing Pitcher: Tyler Clippard


This one was a heartbreaker for Toronto. After a phenomenal spot-start for Sam Gaviglio, and a four-run rally in one inning, the A’s came storming back to overtake the lead, also in one inning. Sean Manaea was facing the Jays’ lineup, and they got two aboard in the 2nd thanks to a walk and an error on a force attempt. Kendrys Morales even stole second, but they were stranded. Yangervis Solarte took a leadoff double in the 4th, and Kevin Pillar walked behind him, but Russell Martin hit into a double play.


The Jays put up a four-spot in the 5th after the leadoff man Dwight Smith Jr. was hit with a pitch, and Gio Urshela hit a two-run homer. With one out, Josh Donaldson walked and Justin Smoak singled. Solarte doubled to score Donaldson and Pillar hit a sac fly that scored Smoak. Manaea was gone after that inning, then Morales doubled to lead off the 6th and was left there.


Gaviglio only allowed one walk, and it was to the last batter he faced. He’d allowed six hits total, two of them doubles, and stranded them all. He left with one out in the 6th and two men on base. Seung-Hwan Oh came in and walked a batter before he stranded the bases loaded. Oh also pitched the 7th with no trouble. Then John Axford started the 8th, walked one, gave up a single, got a strikeout, and allowed an RBI single. Tyler Clippard was brought in to limit the damage, and walked the pinch-hitter Jed Lowrie to load the bases. Then Chad Pinder hit a grand slam, erasing Toronto’s lead in an instant. The Jays got a walk in each of the 8th and 9th, each with two outs, but couldn’t manage anything more than that.


Game 4: Sunday, May 20th
Jays lose, 2-9
Losing Pitcher: Joe Biagini


It was a close game until the 5th. Luke Maile had kept it that way by throwing out a pair of baserunners. Joe Biagini allowed an unearned run on a double, a wild pitch, and a Josh Donaldson error in the 2nd. Meanwhile, Daniel Mengden was nearly untouchable. The Blue Jays only had four hits, by two batters, and just two of them were off Mengden. Yangervis Solarte singled on a shallow pop-up in the 2nd, but was thrown out trying to stretch a double.



Next, the Jays wasted a two on, nobody out opportunity in the 3rd. Leading off, Kendrys Morales almost flew out in foul territory, but Chad Pinder fell into the seats and didn’t make the catch. Morales singled two pitches later, and Luke Maile walked behind him. Richard Urena laid down a sac bunt to move the runners. Then Curtis Granderson struck out and Donaldson grounded out, ending the inning. They wouldn’t get that chance again, because Granderson and Donaldson were the first of 14 consecutive batters retired by Mengden.


Biagini has struggled in the 5th inning in all of his starts this season, and Sunday was no exception. He began the inning with a walk, an infield single that Donaldson bobbled, and an RBI single. Danny Barnes replaced him with nobody out, and after an RBI groundout Marcus Semien hit a two-run homer, making it 5-0 for the visitors. The top of the 6th was even more of a mess, as Jake Petricka only got one out but all three runs he allowed were unearned. After a leadoff Matt Chapman single, Richard Urena made a fielding error on a force attempt, Jonathan Lucroy got an RBI on an infield single, a forceout put runners at the corners, Aaron Loup came in to pitch, Dustin Fowler hit a would-be sacrifice fly that was dropped by Teoscar Hernandez, which scored two runs and resulted in Fowler getting to third, then Fowler scored on a sac fly by Simien.


Deck McGuire then pitched the 7th and stranded the bases loaded after a double and two walks. He also pitched the 8th and stranded Jed Lowrie, who reached on another error charged to Urena. With Mengden out of the game after seven scoreless innings, the Blue Jays finally got their third hit of the game, a Kendrys Morales single. That single, and a Maile walk, would be left on base. Morales then provided the highlight of the game for the Blue Jays as he was brought in to pitch the 9th inning. He walked one, and got three flyouts. The Jays avoided a shutout with two outs in the bottom half, thanks to a Hernandez walk and a Solarte homer, his team-leading tenth of the year.


Overall Notes:

Jaime Garcia was placed on the disabled list on the 18th (backdated to the 16th) with inflammation in his left shoulder. Deck McGuire was called up in his place, and this necessitated two spot starts over the weekend; Joe Biagini took Garcia’s slot in the rotation on Sunday, and Sam Gaviglio took Marcus Stroman’s on Saturday.


It seemed like there was a shift in weaknesses in this series – after a few weeks of taking losses due to the struggling rotation, they had three pretty good starts (all but Sanchez) and then the bullpen allowed piles of runs. Two different relievers (Tyler Clippard on Saturday and Danny Barnes on Sunday) inherited a pair of runners and then allowed them to score on a home run. The hitters also didn’t help, considering there were two games in which the Oakland starter left with an injury and they couldn’t touch the bullpen; then on Sunday, with the bullpen likely to be worn out, they couldn’t get to the starter at all.


Weirdly Specific Record Alert:

  • Richard Urena had the first sacrifice bunt of the season for the Blue Jays in the 3rd inning on Sunday. They were the last team in the majors yet to execute one.


My favourite player(s) this series: Gaviglio/Morales/Urshela

Sam Gaviglio made his first start of the season and did everything that you could ask for from a spot-starter. He went 5 1/3 scoreless innings, allowed six hits and one walk, and struck out six. It took him 88 pitches to complete his start. He also threw a first-pitch strike to nearly every batter (20 out of 23) that he faced.


Kendrys Morales has been in a slump pretty much all season long, and he did go 4-for-12 in the series with a double (hitting .333) because he only played in three games. However, his reason for being on this list is more for entertainment value than actual contributions to the game. He pitched a scoreless inning on Sunday and didn’t even allow a hit. It’s always funny to see a position player pitching, even if your team is getting blown out. So thanks for the laugh, Kendrys!


Gio Urshela also hit .333 in the series, albeit in a smaller sample size. He was 2-for-6 in three games, two he started and one he pinch-hit in. He also drove in three runs, including the only run on Friday. His two-run homer on Saturday started off the four-run rally, and was his first of the season.


Where we are now:
22-25, .468
4th place in the AL East, 10 games back of New York & Boston


After falling below .500 for the first time since the first series of the year, the Jays have now slipped below Tampa Bay in the standings. They’re still maintaining a healthy 7.5-game lead on the last-place Orioles.


They are off on Monday (even though it’s a national holiday, whose idea was that?) and then the Angels come to town for three games. At 26-21, the Angels are third in their own division. J.A. Happ will face off with Garret Richards on Tuesday. Thursday is a day game, with a 12:37 Eastern start time, and will be available exclusively on Facebook. Shohei Ohtani is not scheduled to pitch in this series, but we’ll likely see him as a hitter.


Follow me on Twitter: @JaysGirlEmily 

If you like us here, like us on Facebook

The 2018 Toronto Blue Jays Minor League Handbook is now available! Visit the Handbook page for more information!

Now is a great time to subscribe to the Blue Jays from Away Premium Content Section!

All photos are copyright Blue Jays from Away (2013-2017) and may not be used without permission.