Pre-Rule 5 Draft Roster Shuffling: What’s Coming For Toronto Blue Jays 40-Man Roster?

Luke Maile

Now that the World Series is over and the two Blue Jays’ free agents (Justin Smoak and Clay Buchholz) have filed, the Jays have a made a few moves ahead of the deadline later this month to add players to the roster in advance of the Rule 5 draft at the Winter Meetings.


banner ad


First the moves: The Jays claimed Anthony Bass off of waivers and DFA’ed Ryan Dull. Dull cleared waivers while the Jays also put pitchers Buddy Boshers and Brock Stewart through waivers and sent all three outright to the Buffalo Bisons with Boshers electing free agency on Friday.



This leaves the Jays with four spots on the 40-man roster open. The roster is currently set up as follows:


Jason Adam
Anthony Bass
Ryan Borucki (60-day IL)
Yennsy Diaz
Wilmer Font
Sam Gaviglio
Ken Giles
Anthony Kay
Derek Law
Elvis Luciano
Tim Mayza (60-day IL)
Julian Merryweather
Patrick Murphy
Thomas Pannone
Hector Perez
Sean Reid-Foley
Jordan Romano
Justin Shafer
Matt Shoemaker (60-day IL)
Ryan Tepera
Trent Thornton
Jacob Waguespack
T.J. Zeuch


Danny Jansen
Luke Maile
Reese McGuire


Bo Bichette
Cavan Biggio
Brandon Drury
Vladimir Guerrero Jr.
Rowdy Tellez
Devon Travis (60-day IL)
Richard Urena
Breyvic Valera


Anthony Alford
Jonathan Davis
Derek Fisher
Randal Grichuk
Lourdes Gurriel Jr. (60-day IL)
Teoscar Hernandez
Billy McKinney


Matt Shoemaker

As you can see, there are several players on the 60-day IL. Gurriel, Borucki and Mayza will certainly have roster spots to return to shortly. I don’t believe that the Blue Jays will tender contracts to Shoemaker, Travis or Maile. The rumours are out there that the Jays will non-tender Shoemaker and re-sign him to a deal that is probably less money than his arbitration estimate may get him. The Jays could also non-tender Maile and re-sign him to a minor league deal with a major league option, giving the Jays some depth as their higher end minor league catchers work their way up the system (their two best catching prospects, Alejandro Kirk and Gabriel Moreno, were in A-ball in 2019 while Riley Adams spent most of the year in Double-A). Should the Jays wait until after the Rule 5 draft to re-sign Shoemaker, it would give the Jays four spots to protect players.


Hector Perez, Photo by Kristin Basnett

I also think that the Jays may cut a couple of guys loose from the 40-man roster. Jason Adam is at the top of the list as a guy who has an electric arm but some control issues but he’s pitched well when healthy and still has two options. Hector Perez also still has two minor league options and has lots of potential but has also shown that he has a lot of work to do in terms of finding his control/command. Justin Shafer now has just one minor league option and has also been sent outright to the minors once, meaning that if the Jays try it again, he can elect free agency, so he is a guy they could keep.

On the infield, Breyvic Valera is a candidate to go on waivers. The 27-year-old was picked up when Bo Bichette got injured as another depth piece for the club’s infield. Valera has been a fringe major leaguer for three years now and used his final minor league option in 2019. Finally, if any outfielder gets DFA’ed to make room for someone to be put on the 40-man, it’s probably going to be Jonathan Davis. Unfortunately, while I’m a huge fan of his, he likely has the lowest ceiling of any of the outfielders on the 40-man roster.


So, if the Blue Jays create as many as three more roster spots, they can protect seven players in the Rule 5 draft but I think it will a lower number, closer to four or five. I’ll have a companion piece to this one that looks at realistic Rule 5 eligible players and who I think the Jays will protect.


If you like us here, like us on Facebook!

The 2019 Toronto Blue Jays Minor League Handbook is available now! Visit the Handbook page for more information!

Now is a great time to subscribe to the Blue Jays from Away Premium Content Section!

All photos are copyright Blue Jays from Away (2013-2019) and may not be used without permission.

One thought on “Pre-Rule 5 Draft Roster Shuffling: What’s Coming For Toronto Blue Jays 40-Man Roster?

Comments are closed.